"In a star turn, Anna Sheehan applies all the right dry wit, snark, and disregard for the patriarchy to the mysterious Shelby. She brings the character with a traumatic past to life well, from the moment she returns to school after an extended absence with awkwardness that is not awkward to witness, to her big reveal at the end of Act 1 that the audience was waiting for, which she performed with committed vengeance. (She was giving Elizabeth Gillies as Jade in Victorious in the best way possible.)"